January 1, 2023
While doing research for a book about her high school philosophy teacher, who taught students to question everything, Viren was waylaid when her wife, Marta, was notified that she was being investigated for sexual misconduct at the university where they both teach. While striving to uncover the accuser and prove Marta's innocence, Viren was drawn back to her high school teacher's reflections on the nature and nuances of truth.
Copyright 2023 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
April 15, 2023
An immersive look into how lies and misconstrued truths can capture the psyches of those willing to listen. In this philosophical follow-up to her essay collection, Mine, New York Times Magazine contributor and creative writing instructor Viren chronicles two instances when the ramifications of lies nearly derailed her life. The author begins with her high school years, writing about her teacher Dr. Whiles, who challenged his classes. Whiles was revered by his students, including the author, as an all-knowing figure, someone you desperately wished to make proud with your work. That is, until he began teaching known conspiracies as truths, planting toxic seeds into the minds of impressionable students. In reflecting on her time in class, Viren writes that she was bothered by "the sense that it's not just the individual facts that are wrong, it's the whole premise. Yet no one else seems to be screaming, so I feel crazy for wanting to." As the author was compiling research for this initial topic, she learned about anonymous sexual assault accusations made against her wife, Marta, a fellow professor. Now with a future job on the line and her wife's reputation in jeopardy, Viren worked to dismantle the lies. "One story can easily interrupt another, just as questions build one atop the next," she writes. "The past may mirror the present but the future also casts its shadow back on us." Ruminating on these experiences, Viren investigates the wider concept of truth. Drawing from the work of Socrates, the author aligns her memoir around the allegory of the cave and what could happen if one discovers deeper truths beyond a manufactured reality. Throughout, Viren examines a wide range of relevant questions--e.g., What is the appropriate punishment for these lies, and how can someone move forward from this state of cognitive dissonance? A compelling and propulsive memoir that interrogates the nature of truth and trust.
COPYRIGHT(2023) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Starred review from April 10, 2023
Past and present collide in this propulsive, one-of-a-kind meditation on truth and conspiracy from Viren (Mine), based on her viral essay of the same name. “This all started after the election,” Viren begins, “when the main narrative I kept hearing was that only uneducated whites believed the lies that were being told.” At first, she set out to write a book about her charismatic high school philosophy teacher, whose instruction sometimes bordered on conspiracy theory, interviewing teachers and classmates from her past to pick at the ways reasonable people can be manipulated to believe far-flung fictions. Then Viren’s wife received an email accusing her of sexual misconduct at the university where both worked, and Viren tapped into her background as an investigative journalist to untangle the accusations and clear her wife’s name. Against the social and political instability of the last seven years, Viren seamlessly weaves her parallel narratives into a bigger picture take on the nature of truth: “One story can easily interrupt another, just as questions build one atop the next,” she observes of the book’s overlapping threads. The result is a mesmerizing page-turner pulled tight with psychological tension. This is breathtaking stuff. Agent: Matt McGowan, Frances Goldin Literary.
Starred review from April 15, 2023
When memoirist and professor Sarah Viren was in high school in Florida in the 1990s, she had an impactful philosophy teacher who instructed his students to question everything and then began incorporating into lesson plans conspiracy theories, including Holocaust denialism. Decades later, after Viren was offered a job at the University of Michigan, another applicant falsified a series of anonymous Title IX complaints about Viren's partner, also a professor, thus sabotaging the job offer (a story Viren told in a widely read 2020 New York Times Magazine article). These two experiences intertwine in To Name the Bigger Lie, and both stories are gripping; they unfurl with a sense of suspenseful foreboding to show how lies can tear apart the fabric of everyday life and our most intimate relationships. But underlying them is a more groping, philosophical inquiry that chases the implications of Plato's Allegory of the Cave to probe our sense of what is real, how we know, and, most importantly, how we come to that knowledge together. Ultimately, Viren argues less for the pursuit of truth than the pursuit of understanding, and the necessity of this--of "acknowledging the truth of one another's lived experience"--as a social responsibility. This, she says, is the work of storytelling.
COPYRIGHT(2023) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
May 1, 2023
Viren (Mine) explores the nature of truth and lies. As a high school student, Viren was admitted to a magnet program where she took a class on the history of knowledge that opened her mind to philosophical concepts, but the charismatic teacher also used conspiracy theories such as Holocaust denial as a teaching method. Viren here reflects on the effects of engaging with conspiracy theories on her classmates and herself. Each person remembers their time in that class and with the instructor differently, which prompts the author to consider the nature of truth and reality. Years later, Viren's wife Marta is falsely accused of sexual misconduct at the university where they both teach; later, Viren is offered a job at another educational institution, which prompts her to think more about the ways in which lies have impacted her life. This epistolary book is the result of that introspection and indicates how the author processed her thoughts and fears. She uses philosophy--particularly Plato's allegory of the cave, which examines the link between one's senses and the ways people gain knowledge--to interrogate these concepts. VERDICT A poignant musing on the changing nature of truth.--Rebekah Kati
Copyright 2023 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.